sekundaer replied to the topic Updated Definitions of F in the forum General Psychology 6 years, 4 months ago
I like the idea of getting beyond associating F with emotionality, which does not seem valid, and the biotic/abiotic thesis is interesting. The dimension thinking-feeling seems to have been a headache from the beginning, I have always wondered why Jung choosed the word if he did not believe F was about feelings. The effect have been that the…Read more
Supah Protist replied to the topic Intelligence & Abstraction vs Association/N in the forum General Psychology 6 years, 4 months ago
@safsom is another way to rephrase the constrained vs. unhinged dichotomy as differences vs. similarities between objects?
Also, if NT vs. SF is Unhinged vs. Constrained, is there another dichotomy for ST vs. NF?
Supah Protist replied to the topic Updated Definitions of F in the forum General Psychology 6 years, 4 months ago
I don’t think people can withhold recognition of agency from their perceptions of biotic systems and still interface with that system successfully. Slave owners may have treated and seen their slaves inhumanely, but they certainly treated and saw them as willed agents with agendas, intentions or desires. You wouldn’t punish a shovel if it wasn’t…Read more
Juan E. Sandoval replied to the topic Upcoming Changes to Fi/Ti, and F Attitudes in the forum General Psychology 6 years, 4 months ago
I’m still a bit confused. I don’t see how the self can be abiotic. “A funny person” is still a person and this biotic.
It may be only in word but not in experience -- depending on the context. The word "person" can be an object too.
To give an example, across history, people have treated other people as inhuman. A slave may have been thought of…Read more
Supah Protist replied to the topic Upcoming Changes to Fi/Ti, and F Attitudes in the forum General Psychology 6 years, 4 months ago
I’m still a bit confused. I don’t see how the self can be abiotic. “A funny person” is still a person and this biotic. Perhaps if Ti said “We’re all bags of water and electricity” or “We’re all stardust” that would be more abiotic? Maybe I just answered my own question? “I’m a funny person” in the way you described seems like it may be an example…Read more
Rickus replied to the topic Seelie & Adaptive vs. Unseelie & Directive: Is it Related to Conflict Avoidance? in the forum Model 1 Discussions 6 years, 4 months ago
I identify with being Seelie most of the time, I am mostly patient and forgiving, but there are certain moments with certain family members or strangers who catch me off guard, I can become really angry and aggressive and really push boundaries without taking that person's position into perspective, like if that authority figure does something…Read more
Juan E. Sandoval replied to the topic Upcoming Changes to Fi/Ti, and F Attitudes in the forum General Psychology 6 years, 4 months ago
How can Ti analyze the self, or another person if it doesn’t recognize “cognitive agents”? The self and other people are necessarily “cognitive agents”.
Simple 🙂 Ti will either analyze the self as an abiotic object (as a 'thing'), or it will analyze the definition of the person's cognitive-agency provided to it by Fe (Je).
This baton pass can…Read more
