sekundaer replied to the topic Updated Definitions of F in the forum General Psychology 6 years, 4 months ago
Just want to add that I do not claim to have knowledge about development/integration of CT functions (which it could seem like if I did in the above) but I have many years of experience working with sub-personalities, and since uncovering opposites to conscious parts of our psyche (‘shadows’) and working on the integration of these follow a…Read more
Rua replied to the topic Exploring links between psychoanalysis and CT - discord convo port in the forum General Psychology 6 years, 4 months ago
A topic after my own heart <3 I am not nearly adept enough in psychoanalytic theory to make arguments from that dimension, nor do I have any interest in doing so, but I would like to add a less theoretical perspective.
Starting with a re-evaluation of my own prior misconceptions: I once thought that non-conscious functions were 'blocked', but…Read more
safsom replied to the topic Exploring links between psychoanalysis and CT - discord convo port in the forum General Psychology 6 years, 4 months ago
A critique of systematic frameworks of individuation (Jung's)
I am personally of the belief that individuation as a phenomenon cannot be systematically modeled, and particularly that Jung's framework for it is glaringly incomplete. Before delving into specific criticisms of the ideas that have been outlined above, however, I think that it is…Read more
Juan E. Sandoval replied to the topic Exploring links between psychoanalysis and CT - discord convo port in the forum General Psychology 6 years, 4 months ago
Amazing post Umbi, glad you posted it! Sorry if I end up disagreeing a lot below. I think you did a great job recapping Jung but I may be of a different opinion in many ways.
Jung's hypothesis about human development
I am still reading Jung's work, but so far I tend to differ slightly with him on the aspirational aim of the psyche. I am mostly…Read more
Umbilical Sphere started the topic Exploring links between psychoanalysis and CT - discord convo port in the forum General Psychology 6 years, 4 months ago
[Im posting this at request of aubs, so we can continue discussion here. Originally discord content.]
there are deep connections between function typology and depth psychology in general, we cannot compartmentalise the limbic system and the neocortex from either a psychological or neurological perspective - neurologically, the cortex is deeply…Read more
Rua replied to the topic Revisiting Flat Affect's Nomenclature in the forum General Psychology 6 years, 4 months ago
“Hey, he looks FeSi, double extroverted. And his affect looks weighted”
versus
“Hey, he looks FeSi double extroverted. And his affect looks fallen.”
You're almost certainly correct that 'fallen' is easier to incorporate into sentences in general, though I find the first example rather easy to rearrange for concision and reduced clumsiness with…Read more
Juan E. Sandoval replied to the topic Revisiting Flat Affect's Nomenclature in the forum General Psychology 6 years, 4 months ago
‘Weighted’ has a few advantages to me, but admittedly if one wanted to pinpoint a specific definition from it, nothing matches as well as ‘Fallen’ for what we’re describing.
Yes, Fallen seems to 'pinpoint' it most to me too, for the reasons you mentioned. And to me it also has the added advantage of being easy to say/communicate. Trying it out in…Read more
