Cognitive Typology | Supah Protist | Activity https://cognitivetype.com/members/supahprotist/activity/ Activity feed for Supah Protist. Thu, 30 Jul 2026 13:53:52 +0000 https://buddypress.org/?v= en-US 30 hourly 2 4449ab7fb17986a7c5d9145ecd8b8eaa Supah Protist replied to the topic Hello!! New to the community. in the forum The General Hall https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/hello-new-to-the-community/#post-31762 Wed, 13 Jul 2022 13:03:42 +0000 I think people do volunteer readings on the discord.

]]> 0 f1525ce718ca70dd62ca23fc1fb05bf7 Supah Protist replied to the topic Jordan Peterson personality in the forum The General Hall https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/jordan-peterson/#post-31748 Wed, 06 Jul 2022 02:29:32 +0000 I think most people here would argue that what you’re noticing is his developmental level. He’s FeNi ||-| last time I checked, which means his Se, the function you’re not seeing, is unconscious. So good eye I suppose? I don’t necessarily agree with this typing from my own perspective, but that’s how I would explain what you’re seeing using the C…Read more

]]> 0 f9584e7f9187422cd13c8806f67a2d8d Supah Protist replied to the topic Model 2: Mechanistic (D+) vs Negentropic (L+) in the forum Model 2 Discussions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/model-2-mechanistic-d-vs-negentropic-l/#post-31293 Sun, 15 May 2022 20:35:32 +0000 I’ve been thinking about the different fields of science with respect to typology. Is it possible that if F is biotic ie biological then T is not abiotic but perhaps more accurately formal or computational? Maybe something like this:

Science T F
S Physical Biological
N Formal Social

Because there is at least a social distinction b…Read more

]]> 0 6605b63b32f53752274f5578d6429225 Supah Protist replied to the topic Zeptoform as Ti+Ni 'Cabalism' in the forum Beta https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/zeptoform-as-tini-cabalism/#post-31132 Sat, 23 Apr 2022 19:51:50 +0000 Not really. The four basic dichotomies assumes by the first matrix are Pe vs. Pi, Je vs. Ji, SeNi vs. NeSi and TeFi vs. FeTi. The other matrices have different fundamental dichotomies.

]]> 0 6e19913fe3c79b1f67b8bb9cb3370290 Supah Protist replied to the topic Zeptoform as Ti+Ni 'Cabalism' in the forum Beta https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/zeptoform-as-tini-cabalism/#post-31129 Sat, 23 Apr 2022 19:12:03 +0000 Thanks. It’s actually 4D. In 3 dimensions it would look like a torus.

]]> 0 ea7ea21b7619a04a23d80bbd9fb9d6b8 Supah Protist replied to the topic Zeptoform as Ti+Ni 'Cabalism' in the forum Beta https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/zeptoform-as-tini-cabalism/#post-31126 Sat, 23 Apr 2022 18:43:01 +0000 I see your zeptoform and raise you one tesseract: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/118Fhjlpla6SGlY-rpr0j5MygqMrt9RbX26ztrhnR888/edit

]]> 0 1755935099958e0f16b5206dc2b4a9b9 Supah Protist started the topic John Vervaeke: Ni Theory in the forum Model 1 Discussions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/john-vervaeke-ni-theory/ Tue, 09 Nov 2021 19:57:56 +0000 From a behavioral perspective, Vervaeke seems to be discussing Ni in this playlist: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLND1JCRq8Vuh3f0P5qjrSdb5eC1ZfZwWJ

It’s called “Awakening from the meaning crisis”.  Themes include shamanism, psychotechnologies, metacognition, and meaning. It’s a historical overview of how we’ve interpreted reality.

]]> 0 4a346675e1f8b34c48e60d80f2d96f1a Supah Protist replied to the topic Pe/Pi/Ji/Je correspond to Big Five clusters in the forum General Psychology https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/cognitive-functions-do-match-big-five-aspects/#post-30315 Fri, 05 Nov 2021 22:49:08 +0000 Another relevant paper on this topic: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11097-021-09768-5

And accompanying YouTube video: https://youtu.be/nJPQhRuWjXc

John Vervaeke and Garri Hovhannisian discuss the 10 aspects of the big five as relevance realizing opponent processes.

]]> 0 bd9eeac8890d2bb4903fb0f2516e6b56 Supah Protist replied to the topic Vultology Quiz #6 in the forum Vultology & Learning Center https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/vultology-quiz-6/#post-26098 Thu, 01 Apr 2021 22:24:56 +0000 I made some tables based on the quiz results:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1sf-oone6T8bXNUNAiqssuLGNNfi_NHGp6utX-tMgxjU/edit?usp=sharing

Based on these aggregations, Ceema is an ENFJ, Azza is an ENFJ and Michael is an ESTJ.

]]> 0 36482b81048705679f689bc655d0f683 Supah Protist replied to the topic Vultology Quiz #6 in the forum Vultology & Learning Center https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/vultology-quiz-6/#post-26077 Sat, 27 Mar 2021 17:40:06 +0000 I’m in

]]> 0 d653f03ac436c43e866460ce2be993ec Supah Protist replied to the topic Model 2: The P Systems in the forum Model 2 Discussions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/model-2-the-p-systems-draft/#post-25831 Sun, 24 Jan 2021 15:38:11 +0000 Haven’t read this all the way through yet, but this mirrors some aspects of quantum mechanics/field theory.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complementarity_(physics)

“The more localized the position-space wavefunction, the more likely the particle is to be found with the position coordinates in that region, and correspondingly the mom…Read more

]]> 0 5e09a91524edd434163bb508806b35d2 Supah Protist replied to the topic Psychological Surveys in the forum General Psychology https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/psychological-surveys/page/4/#post-25438 Tue, 22 Dec 2020 02:12:41 +0000

]]> 0 8769e508ca88bf9de998e1bcc483d25d Supah Protist replied to the topic Redefining "S" in the forum Model 1 Discussions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/redefining-s/#post-23971 Thu, 24 Sep 2020 22:48:39 +0000 @auburn, what’s the difference between “Registering mental objects as discontinuous and discrete” (S) and “Definitional processing” (J-)?

]]> 0 cc93470aeee0b93b7ef19cdea1868f4e Supah Protist replied to the topic [Ti] Reductionism in the forum Type Specific https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/ti-reductionism/#post-23940 Thu, 24 Sep 2020 18:17:58 +0000 @bella thanks for the response. I don’t think I’m seeing the relationship between the two phenomena I described and the passages you quoted. Regarding the first phenomenon I described, I’m seeing more alignment with e quote you provided that describes IT. The question of “How do you know that?” seems to be requesting a linguistic justifica…Read more

]]> 0 9eb62261b135a6b185ba547f7e09e56c Supah Protist replied to the topic Updated Definitions of F in the forum General Psychology https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/updated-definitions-of-f/page/2/#post-21036 Tue, 14 Jul 2020 13:37:48 +0000 I think is has already been touched on to an extent, but I think that the description of Fi as “uncoordinated emotional expression” isn’t actually that descriptive. The term irrational has the same problem, it only says what perception is not, not what it is. Saying a type of emotional expression is not coordinated isn’t a complete descrip…Read more

]]> 0 c140e7f49c6620f293e99c4f8c430593 Supah Protist replied to the topic Updated Definitions of F in the forum General Psychology https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/updated-definitions-of-f/#post-20992 Sun, 12 Jul 2020 20:07:02 +0000 "Anyway, since Ti is not the aspect of the oscillation that holds the ‘a priori’ of a cognitive agent, but that is allotted to the objective (Fe), this means that the Fe-Ti oscillation tends to be more inclined towards a belief in an [Other] or [Cosmos], or some externality, that is fundamentally the source of will and living qualities."

This see…Read more

]]> 0 ad50911cc215405c2489766555a28a5a Supah Protist replied to the topic Intelligence & Abstraction vs Association/N in the forum General Psychology https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/intelligence-abstraction-vs-association-n/#post-20951 Sat, 11 Jul 2020 16:05:11 +0000 @safsom is another way to rephrase the constrained vs. unhinged dichotomy as differences vs. similarities between objects?

Also, if NT vs. SF is Unhinged vs. Constrained, is there another dichotomy for ST vs. NF?

]]> 0 131a7cf5979af2a075d410fd350bdc7d Supah Protist replied to the topic Updated Definitions of F in the forum General Psychology https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/updated-definitions-of-f/#post-20944 Sat, 11 Jul 2020 15:28:36 +0000 I don’t think people can withhold recognition of agency from their perceptions of biotic systems and still interface with that system successfully. Slave owners may have treated and seen their slaves inhumanely, but they certainly treated and saw them as willed agents with agendas, intentions or desires. You wouldn’t punish a shovel if it was…Read more

]]> 0 e7381a6f317e901fd2ca33140a6afdc5 Supah Protist replied to the topic Upcoming Changes to Fi/Ti, and F Attitudes in the forum General Psychology https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/upcoming-changes-to-fi-ti-and-f-attitudes/#post-20925 Sat, 11 Jul 2020 12:54:25 +0000 I’m still a bit confused. I don’t see how the self can be abiotic. “A funny person” is still a person and this biotic. Perhaps if Ti said “We’re all bags of water and electricity” or “We’re all stardust” that would be more abiotic? Maybe I just answered my own question? “I’m a funny person” in the way you described seems like it may be an example…Read more

]]> 0 30ecfe8f7d8e4ce04285b5a35445e9ba Supah Protist replied to the topic Updated Definitions of F in the forum General Psychology https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/updated-definitions-of-f/#post-20909 Fri, 10 Jul 2020 15:43:44 +0000 "Ti can analyze the self, or another person, or an idea. It is open in that way."

How can Ti analyze the self, or another person if it doesn't recognize "cognitive agents"? The self  and other people are necessarily "cognitive agents".

]]> 0 c9a379cab6e5ff2ca94e92c12d05c677 Supah Protist replied to the topic Function Quadrants - Preparing to Rewrite in the forum Model 1 Discussions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/function-quadrants-preparing-to-rewrite/#post-20886 Fri, 10 Jul 2020 03:09:23 +0000 It may be useful to conceptualize PiJi (I) and PeJe (E) as both “environments” in their own right. I think the same might go for PeJi (P) and JePi (J) as well. Well, actually it depends on what you are attempting to capture from a phenomenological perspective. Can all of consciousness experience be split up by these bifurcations? Is cognitive typ…Read more

]]> 0 cbadd29a669ad166d27e7c3348c46b9a Supah Protist replied to the topic Function Quadrants - Preparing to Rewrite in the forum Model 1 Discussions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/function-quadrants-preparing-to-rewrite/#post-20871 Fri, 10 Jul 2020 00:03:31 +0000 The idea of "thinking as you speak" seems to be well reflected in the diagram I shared. Thinking as you speak and specifically "immediate feedback with the environment" seem to imply a stimulus-response loop; that's what feedback means. I think all of the oscillations may be involved in different types of feedback loops. Perhaps decompression is a…Read more

]]> 0 981a2b4cb8314ab4b27e3c620f8a5445 Supah Protist replied to the topic Dichotomy Maps in the forum Model 1 Discussions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/dichotomy-maps/#post-20865 Thu, 09 Jul 2020 18:10:52 +0000 Socionics has dichotomies for these already. S and T are both "External" meaning they are explicit while N and F are both "Internal" meaning they are implicit. S and F are both "Involved" meaning they are visceral or somatic while N and T are both "Detached" meaning they are abstract or mental. So one could think of Beta types as being "External…Read more

]]> 0 5f35b7e7b313d008aeafbbc656a0788d Supah Protist started the topic Dichotomy Maps in the forum Model 1 Discussions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/dichotomy-maps/ Wed, 08 Jul 2020 16:45:27 +0000 Here’s a diagram that maps out the jungian dichotomies.
https://cognitivetype.com/wp-content/uploads/hm_bbpui/20840/5w3wgazqujkzamrgllh55nemyvwqm260.jpeg
The left diagram seems to be accounted for in the new Quadra descriptions, but I think the middle and right diagrams may be useful additions to the theory as well. If the energetics and their oscillations are fully described, it would make sense to fully define the functions and their o…Read more

]]> 0 8f8e494ec35491db287c888c09d16712 Supah Protist replied to the topic Notes on Methodology, Experiments & Protocol in the forum Official & Introductions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/notes-on-methodology-experiments-protocol/#post-20836 Wed, 08 Jul 2020 15:29:51 +0000 I guess we see the jungian cognitive architecture differently. Or perhaps, more accurately, we have different hopes as to what it is a theory of. The type of theory I'm after is essentially one of universal biological processes (like the Free Energy Principle) whereas you seem to be aiming at a more local theory. I do think Neojungian theories may…Read more

]]> 0 8b2d1854cb9697caf93a9b7fe6578b5b Supah Protist started the topic Functional Conflict in the forum Model 1 Discussions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/functional-conflict/ Tue, 07 Jul 2020 19:25:38 +0000 I think I may be experiencing a conflict between two functions. On the one hand, I’m trying to understand myself, which I associate with the Fi myth of Edin, but on the other hand I keep deconstructing what I uncover which I associate with the Ti myth of Alin. This makes sense on some level since Ti and Fi are opposed in many theories, but on a…Read more

]]> 0 f5caec4442c64ec49f8f7470b852d18e Supah Protist replied to the topic Notes on Methodology, Experiments & Protocol in the forum Official & Introductions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/notes-on-methodology-experiments-protocol/#post-20816 Sun, 05 Jul 2020 22:20:41 +0000 @auburn, I don't see how what I understand as an interest can be primarily environmental. By interest, I'm referring to innate predispositions as opposed to contextual availabilities. For example, people get hungry regardless of whether or not there is food present. I don't think environment proximity accounts for people's choice of vocational…Read more

]]> 0 719f8dbbef06c85c416bf140343e0e52 Supah Protist replied to the topic Notes on Methodology, Experiments & Protocol in the forum Official & Introductions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/notes-on-methodology-experiments-protocol/#post-20808 Sun, 05 Jul 2020 19:01:38 +0000 @auburn is cognitive type not intended to model domain of interest? I think this is question of scope. I'm not clear on what aspects of psychology cognitive type is attempting to model. Cognition is not a well defined term in my opinion. Neuroscience studies the nervous system, a structure that is easily identifiable in organisms that have one.…Read more

]]> 0 1d50af35bf544c3acdb85628429ceb29 Supah Protist replied to the topic Notes on Methodology, Experiments & Protocol in the forum Official & Introductions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/notes-on-methodology-experiments-protocol/#post-20797 Sun, 05 Jul 2020 14:44:24 +0000 So how important should behavior be in determining someone’s type? This is the point I was getting at with the video I made awhile back. Let’s say that DJ Khaled and Neil deGrasse Tyson have the same vultology. How then are their behavioral differences to be accounted for. If cognitive typology is to have any predictive power, shouldn’t ident…Read more

]]> 0 15ec6e4bcc0e73e70518f1a404f3932b Supah Protist started the topic Function Quadrant Opposition in the forum Model 1 Discussions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/function-quadrant-opposition/ Sat, 04 Jul 2020 18:04:24 +0000 Je and Ji are opposite forms of rationality and Pe and Pi are opposite forms of irrationality. They are both opposing pairs of the same underlying process In this case, what are JePi (J) and PeJi (P) opposite forms of and what are JePe and JiPi opposite forms of? Proponents of the OPS would say that E and I are opposing forms of energy management…Read more

]]> 0 d33a55b81774af0f78ed8d26b9acc98a Supah Protist started the topic The ACT-R Cognitive Architecture and Cognitive Typology in the forum General Psychology https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/the-act-r-cognitive-architecture-and-cognitive-typology/ Sat, 04 Jul 2020 17:31:21 +0000 This is a diagram of the ACT-R Cognitive Architecture.

A cognitive architecture is a computational model of the mind that can can be simulated on a compter.

In my opinion, the ACT-R Cognitive Architecture's Intentional, Declarative, Manual and Visual Modules may correlate with the Ji, Pi, Je and Pe functions respectively.

Ji is described by…Read more

]]> 0 c75ae7a853f01519786161213fc85d47 Supah Protist replied to the topic Function Quadrants - Preparing to Rewrite in the forum Model 1 Discussions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/function-quadrants-preparing-to-rewrite/#post-20763 Sat, 04 Jul 2020 14:16:07 +0000 I think this links up well with my recent thoughts on jungian cognitive architecture.

Recently, I’ve been more inclined to consider the connections between the rational and irrational functions as fundamental. I know you haven’t necessarily advocated for that interpretation in the above post. What are your current thoughts on potential int…Read more

]]> 0 1c4f6522ffd8dbba65806a7b4a4a7492 Supah Protist replied to the topic Brainstorming Scientific Experiment Designs in the forum General Psychology https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/brainstorming-scientific-experiment-designs/#post-20266 Sat, 23 May 2020 18:13:11 +0000 I think I may need to contextualize this discussion.

Experiments test falsifiable hypotheses.

What falsifiable hypothesis do you want to test?

If there are several, feel free to list them.

]]> 0 23d0343c401ddf46896fcca2d16157f5 Supah Protist replied to the topic Brainstorming Scientific Experiment Designs in the forum General Psychology https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/brainstorming-scientific-experiment-designs/#post-20261 Sat, 23 May 2020 17:15:28 +0000 I think what I meant by “dichotomous signal” is referencing the interpretative nature of the reading that would be done. The dichotomy can be used to interpret the data, but I don’t think it should be used in gathering the data. Setting up a dichotomous signal library makes people choose between two options, which would mean that they may bias…Read more

]]> 0 d0f4630cefec463d1919c7a1b0e84232 Supah Protist replied to the topic Brainstorming Scientific Experiment Designs in the forum General Psychology https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/brainstorming-scientific-experiment-designs/#post-20255 Sat, 23 May 2020 15:03:06 +0000 I think a big thing to keep in mind is quantification. I’m not sure that measuring people’s opinions on which signals someone is expressing qualifies as objective data. Setting up a protocol that only records the the quantitative correlates of the signals may be more reliable. For example, actually measuring the number of discrete shoulder shr…Read more

]]> 0 0fc171c16a24ecc3fb6d8c5f1f8f973f Supah Protist replied to the topic Suggestions on good Neural Network Resources? in the forum General Psychology https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/suggestions-on-good-neural-network-resources/#post-20246 Thu, 21 May 2020 19:35:16 +0000 Here's some literature on cognitive architectures and personality specifically:

https://www.aaai.org/Papers/Symposia/Spring/2004/SS-04-02/SS04-02-017.pdf

https://www.dropbox.com/s/dt02n4qijz90i62/sun-COGSYS-2014.pdf?dl=0

]]> 0 85315a40743ab02b49300ba8860817be Supah Protist replied to the topic Suggestions on good Neural Network Resources? in the forum General Psychology https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/suggestions-on-good-neural-network-resources/#post-20244 Thu, 21 May 2020 17:54:15 +0000 I think cognitive architectures are related: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_architecture

Also: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bfO4EkoGh40

Check out SOAR, ACT-R, and SIGMA.

Lastly: https://cs.uwaterloo.ca/~jhoey/teaching/cogsci600/papers/laird.standard.aimag.2017.PDF

Don't know if you saw what I linked awhile back, but these are what…Read more

]]> 0 0480ed28417461500cee84ebcc27e16a Supah Protist started the topic [Ti] Reductionism in the forum Type Specific https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/ti-reductionism/ Fri, 01 May 2020 19:51:45 +0000 Do other Ti people experience these phenomena?

Phenomenon 1:

I'll have a thought in the form of a proposition [P]. These propositions can take many forms, such as "I am human" or "The sky is blue".

The proposition will trigger a question that takes the form "How do I know [P]?" Where [P] is the aforementioned proposition.

This may trigger…Read more

]]> 0 4ca15e2a94644bb5f5be9cf4bc2fd2d6 Supah Protist replied to the topic The 'Ti Void' in the forum Model 1 Discussions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/the-ti-void/#post-19384 Mon, 20 Apr 2020 23:45:14 +0000 @alerith I guess I’m indifferent towards it emotionally, but I value its presence. Questions like “How do I know that?” and “What do I mean by that?” are useful in that they protect me from believing untenable thoughts. However, I’m not sure that what I’m experiencing is actually an example of Ti. I’m not asking “What is X?”, but rather “How do…Read more

]]> 0 1476c440099d9eb81d8b81d969a4b335 Supah Protist replied to the topic A Computational Metaphor in the forum Model 2 Discussions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/a-computational-metaphor/page/2/#post-19287 Thu, 16 Apr 2020 19:28:37 +0000 @auburn, I actually have more of a general question. How have you formulated these functional definitions and their computational metaphors from the empirical data?

]]> 0 ec58914ff77d216b58259dddf9d3bcd8 Supah Protist replied to the topic A Computational Metaphor in the forum Model 2 Discussions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/a-computational-metaphor/#post-18890 Thu, 09 Apr 2020 21:09:18 +0000 Congratulations on the first draft of your cognitive architecture!

Observations:

  1. It seems that part of the worldview function (datasets) is referenced by the the explorer function, but not vice versa. Should this be the case if the the two functions are part of the same oscillation.
  2. It seems that in the compass function that an objects are…

Read more

]]> 0 271f90e7b1f3a2eecd812350accb9aea Supah Protist replied to the topic Socionics & Aušra Augustinavičiūtė in the forum Vultology & Learning Center https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/socionics-ausra-augustinaviciute/#post-18839 Tue, 07 Apr 2020 14:59:39 +0000 I’ve already shared this data with @echidna1000 and @auburn, but here it is in case others are curious.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1n8sidNWhMyELuSwAlKTvLa9Ip0FdjsTz5a_9_iai_n4

This sheet compares 81 celebrity typings from WSS and CT. Of the six comparison sheets I’ve made currently comparing the typings of four typology groups, thi…Read more

]]> 0 506a7c4a76f8fd8e991167640656c94a Supah Protist replied to the topic Socionics & Aušra Augustinavičiūtė in the forum Vultology & Learning Center https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/socionics-ausra-augustinaviciute/#post-18812 Mon, 06 Apr 2020 21:13:56 +0000 1) Conductor Brow: Is brow heaviness a factor of usage or anatomy? I think it might be a mixture of both and it may be the case that anatomical features may correlate with psychology, but I wasn’t aware of that signal.

2) Taut Square Cheeks:  I don’t understand how the taut square cheeks signal is read without a smile present.

3) Behavior: Econ…Read more

]]> 0 1db7227adee1acfba70c4d05968b825b Supah Protist replied to the topic Experiment on Cognitive Functions in the forum Model 1 Discussions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/experiment-on-cognitive-functions/#post-18757 Fri, 03 Apr 2020 19:01:43 +0000 “How to” questions could stimulate Je.

]]> 0 b8a4055e819dc5fc19ef158ba1c5ca6f Supah Protist replied to the topic The 'Ti Void' in the forum Model 1 Discussions https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/the-ti-void/#post-18754 Thu, 02 Apr 2020 23:55:26 +0000 I thought “the void” was my pattern of questioning all of my assertions or thoughts. I thought the original Alin Mythology entry encapsulated it well. For me, if this is Alin, it’s not that esoteric or abstract, it’s my asking myself “How do you know that?” “What do you mean by that?” etc. It’s not a sense or anything static, it’s more of the…Read more

]]> 0 8b62a14aedacbb71fcd5ea3e98f411a7 Supah Protist started the topic CT Constructive Criticism in the forum The General Hall https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/ct-constructive-criticism/ Thu, 23 Jan 2020 21:24:56 +0000 I want CT to work, but I don't think it's working.

The main point I address in this video is the lack of behavioral and mythological parallels between members of the same type.

]]> 0 8d628cc190230c8117ba9cce5aaf5a23 Supah Protist started the topic Statistical Typology Project in the forum The General Hall https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/statistical-typology-project/ Fri, 17 Jan 2020 23:08:00 +0000 For those of you who don't know, I've written some code that can calculate statistics based on a collection of typings. For example, if you've been typed as an introvert 10/12 times the code can tell you the probability of getting a result that strong or stronger by random chance. In the case of the prior example the probability would be .0386.…Read more

]]> 0 64ae52f98e6c200dc325544e70c41682 Supah Protist replied to the topic Vultology Quiz #4: 1 Sample! in the forum Vultology & Learning Center https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/vultology-quiz-4-1-sample/page/3/#post-17037 Tue, 14 Jan 2020 01:01:03 +0000 @auburn I think it means that a collective and consistent vocabulary has begun to form. However, this doesn't necessarily mean that what has been identified constitutes a discrete physiological reality. I can share a thought I had recently to illustrate my point. Take colors. Everyone can recognize colors, but color is not a discrete phenomenon,…Read more

]]> 0 b040e47641f4ed5fa6dd3de3f1c381bf Supah Protist replied to the topic Vultology Quiz #4: 1 Sample! in the forum Vultology & Learning Center https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/vultology-quiz-4-1-sample/page/2/#post-17015 Mon, 13 Jan 2020 22:58:42 +0000 Any signal with at least 10 sightings would have a .04 chance of getting the same amount of sightings or more randomly.

The signals with at least 10 sightings are Je-5, Pe-2, Fi-1, and Fi-3.

Additionally, any signal with 2 sightings or less would also have a low chance (.04) of occurring randomly.

There's a lot of those thought and  don't…Read more

]]> 0 6f53db76d9a5561ccdec8195c16feedd Supah Protist replied to the topic Vultology Quiz #4: 1 Sample! in the forum Vultology & Learning Center https://cognitivetype.com/forums/topic/vultology-quiz-4-1-sample/page/2/#post-17013 Mon, 13 Jan 2020 22:44:08 +0000 I calculated some stats on the aggregate results.

These are the odds of getting the same results or stronger by chance.

Any probability less than .05 is commonly regarded as statistically significant.

J/P: .000667

C/R: .746962*

SeNi/NeSi: .000009

TeFi/FeTi: 1.74990416061e-27 (very small)

*Conductor/Reviser signals are calculated as the…Read more

]]> 0